Which Nintendo Games Deserve the Throne? Your Vote Matters

Nintendo has been shaping childhoods — and adult obsessions — for decades. The problem, of course, is that “best” is a messy, affectionate argument: do you reward innovation, influence, nostalgia, or pure, timeless fun? IGN and Nintendo Life have partnered to try to pin that slippery title down by ranking the 100 best Nintendo games of all time — and the fun part is, readers get to weigh in and help shape a separate, user-curated list.

Why this ranking matters

• Lists like these become reference points. They affect retrospectives, collector interest, and even how future generations discover classics.
• Nintendo’s library spans consoles, handhelds, and decades — including third-party games that are now practically synonymous with Nintendo hardware.
• Bringing editorial voices (IGN + Nintendo Life) together with reader votes creates a snapshot of both critical and community taste — and where they diverge.

What’s happening and when

• IGN and Nintendo Life will reveal their editorial-ranked “100 Best Nintendo Games of All Time” across the week of November 10–14, 2025, publishing 20 picks per day until a single Number One is crowned. (nintendolife.com)
• Before the full editorial list goes live, IGN is running a Faceoff-style campaign that lets readers pit games against one another and cast votes to build a reader-driven ranking. Nintendo Life points readers toward that IGN face-off for the community result. (nintendolife.com)

What to expect on the list

• Heavy hitters are almost guaranteed: Zelda, Mario, Metroid, and Mario Kart entries routinely dominate community and editorial best-of lists. Titles like Ocarina of Time, Breath of the Wild, Super Mario World, Super Metroid, and Tears of the Kingdom will be strong contenders given their enduring critical standing and cultural impact. (en.wikipedia.org)
• The collaboration explicitly includes third-party titles that are Nintendo exclusives or inseparable from Nintendo platforms, which means classics from Rare, Square, and other longtime partners could climb higher than in some Nintendo-only rankings. (nintendolife.com)
• Expect conversation-starters: underrated gems, surprising placements, and the inevitable debates about how to weigh influence vs. nostalgia vs. playability in 2025’s context.

Why reader votes can shift the conversation

• Editorial lists reflect a curated perspective — often balancing historical significance, innovation, and craft. Reader lists show what communities actually played, loved, and returned to.
• A passionate niche of fans can push a cult classic up the ranks; conversely, mainstream blockbusters might dominate editorial lists but be checked by readers who prize personal attachment or niche innovation.
• The Faceoff model (pairwise voting) tends to surface both consensus favorites and polarizing picks, making the reader list a lively counterpoint to the editorial ranking. (tech.yahoo.com)

Games I’d watch for interesting placements

• The usual suspects: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time; Super Mario World; The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. These frequently sit near the summit on historic “best of” lists. (en.wikipedia.org)
• Hidden pushes: Niche or regionally beloved titles can bubble up when dedicated communities mobilize — think cult classics that inspired devotion but not always mainstream praise.
• Third-party standouts: Games that, while not developed by Nintendo, feel like Nintendo because of timing, platform identity, or creative synergy — they could shake up the top 100. (nintendolife.com)

A few things to keep in mind when voting

• Timeframe and scope: This ranking considers games released on Nintendo consoles and handhelds across eras — from the NES and Game Boy to Switch and Switch 2 — so balance your nostalgia with an eye for historical impact.
• Personal taste vs. legacy: Do you vote for the game that changed an entire genre, or the one you personally replay every year? Both are valid; the resulting lists will reflect that tension.
• The voting method: Faceoff/pairwise formats favor games that can consistently win head-to-head matchups; a polarizing masterpiece might lose to a broadly loved but less daring title.

What this says about Nintendo’s legacy

This collaboration isn’t just a countdown — it’s a cultural audit. Nintendo’s catalog is diverse: arcade-inspired pick-ups, sprawling RPGs, inventive platformers, and social multiplayer staples. A combined editorial-and-reader snapshot captures more facets of that legacy than either side alone.

Final thoughts

Rankings are arguments as much as they are lists. They invite debate, nostalgia trips, and fresh appreciation for overlooked work. Whether you vote to defend a childhood favorite, champion an underdog, or argue that a revolutionary title deserves the crown, this joint IGN/Nintendo Life effort will create a lively record of what Nintendo means to players in 2025. Expect spirited takes, surprising upsets, and plenty of “How is that above X?!” moments — and that’s the whole point.

Sources

• What Are The 100 Best Nintendo Games? Here's The Chance To Make Your Voice Heard — Nintendo Life. https://www.nintendolife.com/news/2025/11/what-are-the-100-best-nintendo-games-heres-the-chance-to-make-your-voice-heard. (nintendolife.com)

• The 100 Best Nintendo Games Ever Faceoff — IGN (republished/preview context via Yahoo/tech outlets). https://tech.yahoo.com/gaming/articles/100-best-nintendo-games-ever-140000532.html. (tech.yahoo.com)

• The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time — historical context on critical standing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Legend_of_Zelda%3A_Ocarina_of_Time. (en.wikipedia.org)