TL;DR
- Splatoon Raiders hit a 9.3 Metacritic User Score and briefly ranked 7th âbest of all timeâ on the site, despite an 81 critic Metascore and mixed reviews from outlets like The Guardian. [1][2][5]
- The leaderboard position reflects mobilized fans, memeâera behavior (see Disneyâs Cory in the House), and a system that delays negative reviewâbombs for 36 hours but not positive swarms. [1][6][7]
- Expect regression: with ~800 user reviews, a few dozen 0/10s or a wave of 7/10s can mathematically yank Splatoon Raiders out of the allâtime top 10 within weeks. [4]
What the source said
Video Games Chronicle reports that Splatoon Raiders, a Switch 2 spinâoff released on July 23, 2026, sits at 9.3/10 in Metacriticâs User Score and placed 7th on the siteâs allâtime userârated list, while its critic Metascore is 81. [1][3]
The piece flags the known caveats around user ratings: scores skew to 10s and 0s, meme campaigns can distort ranks (e.g., Cory in the House), and Metacriticâs 36âhour hold on new user reviews was meant to slow bombing, not boosting. [1][6][7]
Why it matters
Nintendo just shipped a Switch 2 exclusive intended to move hardware in late July 2026; â7th greatest game of all time on Metacritic (users)â is the kind of social proof that nudges fenceâsitters when amiibo chatter is peaking. [1][3]
Metacriticâs brand sits in the blast radius as well. Its critic Metascore has long shaped marketing decks and investor chatter, but the allâtime user leaderboard mixes expansions, cult classics, and meme targets into a single âGOATâ list that can be captured in a launch week. [1][2]
Original analysis
Splatoon Raiders on Metacritic: signal vs noise
Consensus view: âTopâ10 allâtime user score proves Splatoon Raiders is an allâtimer.â Contrarian read: this ranking mostly proves how quickly a coordinated fandom can overpower a lowâdenominator system that delays early negativity but does not dampen early positivity. [1][7]
Four data points undermine the âallâtimerâ framing:
- The Metascore is 81, not a GOATâtier 90+; that puts it roughly midâpack among 2026 releases. [1]
- The Guardianâs review reads downbeat, a reminder the critic spread isnât universally glowing. [5]
- Metacriticâs 36âhour delay on user scores, added in 2020 after highâprofile bombings, never targeted positive swarms, so celebratory brigades slip through. [7]
- The allâtime user list is a genre soupâfull releases mingle with expansions like Blood and Wine or Frozen Throneâso the ranking bakes apples and oranges into one pie. [1][2]
Namedâstakeholder breakdown:
- Nintendo: Gains launchâwindow marketing copy (âhighest userârated Nintendo game everâ) that pairs with Switch 2 positioning; risk: reputational whiplash if the score normalizes below 9.0. [4]
- Metacritic: Gets traffic spikes but risks erosion of trust in its âallâtimeâ lists if small, recent cohorts can hijack the podium. [2]
- Retail and platform storefronts (Nintendo eShop, Amazon US): âUniversal acclaimâ user badges convert into clicks, but only if the 9.0+ headline survives beyond week one. [2][4]
- Creators and streamers in the Splatoon scene on YouTube and Twitch: A high user score energizes guideâandâchallenge content, sustaining visibility independent of critic takes. [5]
Backâofâenvelope: how fragile is a 9.3?
- Assume ~800 user reviews at 9.3/10 â 9.3 Ă 800 = 7,440 âpoints.â [4]
- Add m zeroâscores. New average = 7,440 Ă· (800 + m).
- To drop to 9.0: 7,440 Ă· (800 + m) = 9.0 â m â 27 new 0/10s.
- To drop to 8.8: 7,440 Ă· (800 + m) = 8.8 â m â 46 new 0/10s.
- Add 200 moderate 7/10s instead: (7,440 + 1,400) Ă· 1,000 = 8.84.
Translation: a small wave of detractorsâor a broader wave of normal playersâwill drag the average out of âGOATâ territory fast. This is classic smallâsample volatility.
A 2Ă2 for reading Metacritic User Scores
- High volume (â„10,000 ratings) + Low variance: Broad acclaim (durable signals; hard to nudge).
- High volume (â„10,000) + High variance: Polarized blockbusters (cultureâwar magnets).
- Low volume (â€1,500) + Low variance: Niche darlings (stable but limited reach).
- Low volume (â€1,500) + High variance: Meme spikes/mobilized fandoms (volatile; Raiders today).
Splatoon Raiders lives in the last quadrant right now: hundreds of 10s, some 0s, and under 1,000 ratingsâexactly the profile that produces eyeâcatching ranks that rarely last. [1][4]
Historical analogue: July 2020âs reviewâbomb saga prompted Metacriticâs 36âhour hold. It reduced instant negativity but didnât address brigading in either direction. Raidersâ Topâ10 moment mirrors The Last of Us Part IIâs early pileâon in reverse: a flood of early sentiment swinging a headline metric before the broader audience shows up. Expect a reversion as late buyers and renters arrive through August 2026. [7]
What others are missing
Coverage fixates on the 9.3 and the â7th of all timeâ headline, but the real story is incentive design. Metacriticâs allâtime user list lacks a prominently displayed minimumâvotes threshold and lumps expansions with full releases, so it rewards mobilized communities at launch; thatâs how a Switch 2âexclusive spinâoff can sit a few rungs from The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time while a TV tieâin like Cory in the House rides irony into the top tier. Systems shape outcomes; here, the system rewards speed of turnout over depth of consensus. [1][2][6]
What to watch next
- By August 31, 2026, Splatoon Raidersâ Metacritic User Score falls below 9.0 as the review base broadens beyond early adopters. [2][4]
- By October 31, 2026, Splatoon Raiders drops out of Metacriticâs allâtime Topâ10 userârated list as additional reviews accumulate. [2]
- By September 30, 2026, Nintendo ships at least one patch (v1.x) that names matchmaking stability or mission repetition in its notes, addressing pain points raised in critic writeâups. [5]
My take
Iâm glad Splatoon finally has a singleâplayerâforward spinâoff that lands for fans, but a launchâweek 9.3 user score is a vibes check, not a verdict. The critic spread at 81 and The Guardianâs cool response tell a different story: good game, not canonizing masterpiece. As a marketing asset for Switch 2, this is gold; as a measure of âallâtime greatness,â itâs foolâs gold. Watch the number melt as the broader audienceânot just the superfansâshows up through Q3 2026. [1][2][5]
Sources
[1] Splatoon Raiders is currently the 7th greatest game of all time on Metacritic, according to User Score â VGC (https://www.videogameschronicle.com/news/splatoon-raiders-is-currently-the-7th-greatest-game-of-all-time-on-metacritic-according-to-user-score/) â News peg and key figures (9.3 user score, 81 Metascore), plus context on memeâdriven anomalies.
[2] Best Games by User Score (AllâTime) â Metacritic (https://www.metacritic.com/browse/game/all/all/all-time/userscore/?sort=%2F) â Confirms Splatoon Raidersâ presence and rank on the allâtime list.
[3] Splatoon Raiders â Nintendo Official Store (https://www.nintendo.com/store/products/splatoon-raiders-switch-2/) â Confirms platform (Switch 2) and release date (July 23, 2026).
[4] âSplatoon Raidersâ is now the best userâreviewed Nintendo game ever â NME (https://www.nme.com/news/gaming-news/splatoon-raiders-best-player-reviewed-nintendo-game-of-all-time-3959406) â Notes 9.3 based on ~800 user reviews and frames relative standing among Nintendo titles.
[5] Splatoon Raiders review â The Guardian (https://www.theguardian.com/games/2026/jul/21/splatoon-raiders-review-nintendo-switch-2) â Provides a more critical assessment to contrast user enthusiasm.
[6] Cory in the House â Know Your Meme (https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/subcultures/cory-in-the-house) â Documents the longârunning metaâjoke and its impact on Metacritic user scores.
[7] Metacritic Will Delay User Reviews For Games â GameSpot (https://www.gamespot.com/articles/metacritic-will-delay-user-reviews-for-games/1100-6479886/) â Confirms the 36âhour waiting period policy and its 2020 context.